WHOLESALE STRATEGY

When to Add a Second Wholesale Marketplace After Faire

Add a second wholesale channel once Faire is producing orders predictably, which for most brands we work with is around month 6. Before then, a second marketplace splits the attention and order velocity Faire rewards early.

when to add a second wholesale marketplace after faire

The right time for when to add a second wholesale marketplace after Faire is once Faire is producing orders predictably, which for most brands we work with lands around month 6. Before that point, a second marketplace splits the attention, inventory, and order velocity that Faire rewards in your first months, and you end up with two average channels instead of one strong one.

That is the short version. The rest of this article covers why Faire comes first, the five numbers that tell you it is producing predictably, what your second-channel options actually are, and how to add one without damaging the channel that is already working.

Why Faire Comes First

Faire connects 800,000+ independent retailers with 100,000+ brands on one B to B marketplace. For most CPG brands it is the fastest path to wholesale orders, which is why we treat it as the foundation of a wholesale strategy for independent retail, not the whole strategy.

Three things make the order of operations matter.

The early window. In the accounts we manage, we have seen new profiles get a momentum window. Profiles that underperform in their first 90 days tend to get buried, and digging out is much harder than launching right with strong listings. Splitting your first quarter between two marketplaces is the easiest way to underperform on both, especially for small businesses with one person running wholesale.

Velocity compounds. According to Faire, its search ranking is weighted on broad patterns over weeks and months, not individual actions, and brand performance is one of its three stated priorities. Faire names product conversion, review rating, return rate, order cancellations, and fulfillment timing as factors. Many small, cleanly fulfilled orders build that track record faster than a few large ones. A second channel that pulls inventory or attention away slows that compounding.

The economics improve as you mature. Faire’s published rule for North American brands is a 25% commission on a retailer’s first marketplace order plus a one-time $10 new-customer fee, 15% on reorders, and 0% on Faire Direct orders from retailers you bring yourself. A brand with a healthy reorder base and its existing retailers on Faire Direct is paying a very different effective rate than a brand in its first month. We break the full math down in What Faire Actually Takes in 2026.

If you want a team to get Faire to that predictable point before you expand, our Faire growth services are built around exactly that sequence.

Five Signs Faire Is Producing Predictably

“Predictable” is not a feeling. These are the benchmarks we check before telling a brand it is ready for a second channel. The first four are our own benchmarks from client work. The Top Shop thresholds are Faire’s published criteria.

Signal

Ready when

Source

Time on a well-built profile

Past the first 90 days, typically around month 6

Our client work

Conversion rate

8% or better in general; 15 to 17% for food brands

Our benchmarks

Reorder rate

40 to 45%

Our benchmarks

Days between orders

40 to 70 days, down from the 100 to 300 days we see on unmanaged profiles

Our benchmarks

Top Shop status

Merchandising score 60+, 5+ orders fulfilled in the quarter, 4.8+ average rating over 12 months, late shipments at or under 10%, missing items at or under 3%

Faire-published

The Top Shop line is worth dwelling on. Faire evaluates it four times a year, at the end of each quarter, and the late-shipment and missing-item limits are exactly what a second channel tends to break first. You can read Faire’s Top Shop program page for the current rules.

One more check that is not a number: are your existing retailers on Faire Direct? If you have wholesale accounts that still order by email, purchase order or invoice, moving them onto your Faire Direct link brings those orders in at 0% Faire commission and cuts the manual steps of invoicing and chasing payment. Eligible retailers also get Faire’s 60-day payment terms instead of your net terms, and Faire handles the payment processing. Faire counts that retailer activity in Faire’s algorithm too. The good news: that is usually a faster win than opening a new marketplace.


Your Options for a Second Channel

“Another marketplace” is only one way to grow independent retail. These are the three routes we see brands take, and when each one fits.

Channel

What it is

When it fits

Check first

Another wholesale marketplace

A second storefront on a platform such as Airgoods, Mable, Handshake, or Juniper Market

Faire is predictable and you can staff a second storefront properly

The platform's current fees and terms, directly from them, and how much its retailer base overlaps with yours on Faire

Direct wholesale program

Retailer relationships outside a marketplace, plus field reps where they make sense

You have reps, or larger retailers who want to buy directly

Whether those retailers could order through your Faire Direct link instead

Distributors

Distribution partners such as UNFI and KeHE

The retailers you want buy through distribution rather than marketplaces

Whether your margins and operations fit a distributor model; it is a separate conversation from marketplaces

We are deliberately not publishing fee comparisons for other marketplaces here. Some charge commission, some charge flat fees, terms change, and the only numbers worth using are the ones each platform gives you on the day you sign up. Check the overlap too. Many of the gift shops, independent boutiques and local retailers you would reach there may already buy from you on Faire.

Field sales reps and marketplaces are complementary, not competitive. Where a brand has an internal rep team, the reps cover in-person relationships and the marketplace covers the digital-first retailer base where the algorithm decides who gets seen.


Questions to Ask Before You Sign Up for a Second Marketplace

Every platform’s sales page looks good. These questions show you what running a second storefront will actually take, and they are worth asking in writing before you list a single product.

  1. What does it cost, all in? Ask for the commission or flat fees on first orders and reorders, any payment processing charges, and any monthly or listing fees. Then compare it with your real Faire mix, not Faire’s headline rate.

  2. Who are the retailers, and how many already buy from you? Ask how big the retailer base is in your product category and region. If most of their buyers are the same gift shops and independent boutiques already ordering from you on Faire, the new channel moves orders around rather than adding them.

  3. What terms do retailers get? Faire’s flexible payment terms are a big part of why retailers place a first order. Ask what the new platform offers on net terms, free shipping and free returns, and who pays for them.

  4. Can you match your minimums? Check whether you can set your own minimum order quantities and order minimums, and whether they can match what you use on Faire. Mismatched minimums confuse retailers who buy from you in both places.

  5. How much work is the catalog? Ask whether you can import your product catalog or have to rebuild product titles, descriptions and product images by hand, and how inventory updates sync between platforms. Manual steps are where stock errors start.

  6. What does support look like? Ask how retailer questions, damaged shipments and disputes are handled, and how quickly their customer support responds to brands.

  7. How do payouts work? Ask when you get paid after an order ships, and who carries the risk if a retailer pays late.

If a platform can’t answer these clearly, that tells you what you need to know.

How to Add a Second Channel Without Hurting Faire

The most common failure we see is not choosing the wrong second channel. It is letting the first one slip while the new one gets set up. Protect these five things.

  1. Keep the Faire cadence. In the accounts we manage, that means retailer messages at least Monday, Wednesday, and Friday, and one to two email campaigns a week. Faire Markets run twice a year, in January and July, and are free to join; according to Faire, Market adds up to 5% on top of your promotion. Do not skip a Market because you are busy launching elsewhere. Our guide to Faire’s marketing tools covers what to keep running.

  2. Ring-fence inventory for best-sellers. Our rule is to flag any best-seller that drops under about 5 units. Inventory updates and order management across two platforms are where stockouts start, and a stockout caused by a new channel shows up on Faire as cancellations and missing items.

  3. Hold your lead times. We treat 4 to 7 days as the safe floor. Tightening lead times to look competitive on a new wholesale platform and then missing ship dates costs you on Faire’s late-shipment metric.

  4. Keep the Faire Direct link everywhere. Email signatures, your website’s wholesale footer, social profiles, line sheets. A second marketplace should not replace the link that brings your own retailers in at 0% Faire commission.

  5. Compare year over year. Wholesale ordering is seasonal. Judge whether the second channel took anything from Faire sales against the same month last year, not last month.

Resist the urge to buy your way into the new channel with deep discounts, and keep your wholesale pricing consistent across platforms. A lower price on a new marketplace undercuts the retailers already buying from you on Faire. High promotion frequency trains retailers to wait for the next sale, and that habit tends to follow your brand across every platform you sell on.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I sell on Faire and another wholesale marketplace at the same time?

Yes. The independent brands that win long-term usually build a portfolio of independent retail channels. The question is timing: add the second one once Faire is producing predictably, which in our client work is around month 6.

Should I launch on two marketplaces at once if I’m new to wholesale?

We advise new brands against it, especially a DTC brand that is new to wholesale. In our experience, profiles that underperform in their first 90 days on Faire get buried and are hard to recover, so a launch deserves your full attention on one platform.

Will a second marketplace hurt my Faire ranking?

Not by itself. Faire ranks on brand performance factors including conversion, review rating, cancellations, and fulfillment timing. If the new channel causes stockouts or late shipments, those show up in your Faire metrics.

Should I move to a cheaper marketplace instead of Faire?

Compare Faire fees against your real mix, not the headline rate. Faire’s commission structure is 15% on reorders and 0% on Faire Direct orders, so a brand with a strong reorder base and its own retailers on Faire Direct pays far less than 25% overall in commission fees.

Is a direct wholesale program better than a second marketplace?

It depends on your retailers. If you have reps or larger accounts that want to buy directly, a direct program can fit, but check first whether those retailers could order through your Faire Direct link.

What to Do Next

Pull your last 90 days in your Faire account and check them against the five signals above: conversion, reorder rate, days between orders, Top Shop status, and Faire Direct coverage. If most of them are at benchmark, you are ready to plan a second channel. If they are not, the fastest growth for your wholesale business is still on Faire. If you want a second opinion on which side of that line you are on, The Prosper Lab will give you an honest answer, including when the answer is to wait.

Ready to meet our team?
Book your 15-minute strategy call.

Inside Faire Growth

Actionable strategies, real-world breakdowns, and proven insights from brands scaling on Faire, when you sign up.

By subscribing, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms.

© 2024 The Prosper Lab LLC. All rights reserved.

Inside Faire Growth

Actionable strategies, real-world breakdowns, and proven insights from brands scaling on Faire, when you sign up.

By subscribing, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms.

© 2024 The Prosper Lab LLC. All rights reserved.

Inside Faire Growth

Actionable strategies, real-world breakdowns, and proven insights from brands scaling on Faire, when you sign up.

By subscribing, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms.

© 2024 The Prosper Lab LLC. All rights reserved.